Our Blogs

RMA is a full service law firm offering end-to-end solution to businesses, corporates as well as individuals.

ESG Disclosures and Greenwashing Liability Under Securities Law

ESG Disclosures and Greenwashing Liability Under Securities Law

Introduction

The global integration of Environmental, Social, and Governance (“ESG”) metrics into mainstream capital markets has transformed corporate sustainability narratives from voluntary branding into vital drivers of investment decisions. In India, this evolution is reinforced by the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s (“SEBI”) expanding reporting framework, notably Regulation 34(2)(f) of the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 (“LODR Regulations”), and mandates requiring top-tier listed entities to publish a Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (“BRSR”).

However, the commercial premium attached to green credentials has spawned a critical regulatory concern: Greenwashing is, ‘making false, misleading, unsubstantiated, or otherwise incomplete claims about the sustainability of a product, service, or business operation.1 While historically viewed as a matter of corporate ethics or marketing, unverified sustainability reporting now threatens market transparency and invites severe corporate liability under Indian securities law.

This Article investigates whether and to what degree the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices related to Securities Market) Regulations, 2003 (“PFUTP Regulations”) impose liability for greenwashing in BRSR disclosures. Additionally, it makes the case that enforcement under the PFUTP regime is better than enforcement under the LODR Regulations or the residual provision under Section 15HB of the SEBI Act, 1992 (“SEBI Act”) because the anti-fraud framework best describes the crime of greenwashing in terms of its nature, associated penalties, and enforcement.

Law Governing ESG Disclosure and Greenwashing in India2

India does not have a single, standalone statute called the “Anti-Greenwashing Act.” Instead, holding a company liable for misleading sustainability claims requires navigating a multi-layered legal web that spans capital market regulations, director duties under company law, and consumer protection statutes. When a company inflates its environmental record, several key provisions are triggered:

1. The SEBI LODR Regulations

1.1. Regulation 34(2)(f) of the LODR Regulations: Mandates that the top 1,000 listed entities include a BRSR as part of their annual disclosures.

1.2. Regulations 4(1)(c) and 4(1)(e) of LODR Regulations: Prohibits misrepresentation, mandating that all disclosures shared with investors and stock exchanges be accurate, adequate, and explicitly clear.

1.3. Section 15HB of the SEBI Act: Serves as the default penalty provision for general reporting violations not involving active fraud, capping fines at INR 1 crore.

2. SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices related to Securities Market) Regulations, 2003

2.1. Regulations 3(a), 4(2)(a), 4(2)(f), and 4(2)(k) of the PFUTP Regulations: Prohibit manipulative and fraudulent trade practices, specifically targeting misstatements or untruthful information designed to induce investors, with liability predicated on the company’s knowledge of the falsity.

2.2. Section 15HA of the SEBI Act, 1992: SEBI can levy penalties reaching up to INR 25 crore or three times the unlawful profit gained, ensuring that the financial benefit of attracting green capital on false pretences is entirely wiped out.

3. Companies Act, 2013

3.1. Section 166(2) of the Companies Act, 2013: Mandates directors to act in good faith, explicitly requiring actions “for the protection of the environment.”

3.2. Section 166(3) of the Companies Act, 2013: Imposes a strict duty of care and diligence, making directors personally liable for approving unverified sustainability targets.

The Regulatory Landscape: From BRSR-to-BRSR Core

India’s sustainability framework has progressively matured from narrative-based disclosures to rigorous, data-centric accountability.

India's sustainability framework is built on a multi-layered regulatory approach. First, through the BRSR mandate, SEBI requires the top 1,000 listed entities by market capitalization to file comprehensive BRSR disclosures as part of their annual reports, mapping performance against core environmental and governance principles. To counter superficial reporting within these disclosures, SEBI introduced the BRSR Core framework, which establishes standardized Key Performance Indicators backed by mandatory third-party assurance. Simultaneously, operating alongside these securities rules, the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s Guidelines for the Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing or Misleading Environmental Claims, 2024 prohibit vague ecological claims (such as “eco-friendly” or “sustainable”) across public communication channels unless they are backed by verifiable evidence.

Greenwashing as Securities Fraud: The PFUTP Pathway

While procedural oversights in filing can trigger minor administrative penalties, substantive misstatements in mandatory ESG disclosures attract severe scrutiny under PFUTP Regulations.

The doctrinal basis for treating these BRSR statements with the same gravity as financial disclosures stems from the Supreme Court's ruling in N. Narayanan v. Adjudicating Officer, SEBI ((2013) 12 SCC 152)3. In this case, the Court upheld a market restraint and a ₹50 lakh penalty against a director whose company published inflated financial results, firmly establishing that disclosure and transparency are the twin pillars of market integrity.

Building on this principle, to trigger PFUTP liability, materiality and investor inducement form the cornerstone of fraud under the framework. False ESG metrics can distort capital allocation just as material misstatements in financial statements do. This reliance standard is evident in SEBI's 12th August 2025 order concerning Dewan Housing Finance Corporation4, where misstatements in financial statements were held to be fraudulent precisely because investors rely on such reports to make market decisions. Consequently, an ESG misstatement must be capable of influencing an investor's decision or exposing the issuer to significant adjudicatory risk, though absolute perfection is not demanded since the BRSR framework applies a standard of “reasonable assurance” assessed on a preponderance of probabilities.

Regarding the mental element and director accountability, provisions like Regulations 4(2)(a), 4(2)(f), and 4(2)(k) of the PFUTP Regulations predicate liability on the knowledge of falsity. While a compliance officer or director who signs off on a BRSR purely as a mechanical duty under 34(2)(f) of LODR Regulations without awareness of errors may not automatically breach these sub-regulations, SEBI is not required to prove explicit deceit to establish overall fraud. Furthermore, if a board appoints an unverified third-party assurance provider or permits conflicts of interest, that compromised verification process serves as strong probative evidence (mens rea) of the issuer's knowledge that the disclosures were unreliable.

Market Positioning and Sector-Specific Materiality5

The legal gravity of an ESG misstatement depends heavily on the industry positioning of the reporting company:

High-Impact Sectors: For carbon-intensive industries (such as fossil fuels, energy, and heavy manufacturing), ESG data directly dictates eligibility for green bonds, sustainability-linked loans, and specialized mutual funds. Misleading statements here carry an exceptionally high likelihood of inducing investor action.

Low-Impact Sectors: Technology and software companies face a higher threshold of materiality under the PFUTP regime, as markets primarily evaluate them on profitability and core capabilities rather than environmental metrics.

Why PFUTP Enforcement is Preferable to LODR Alternatives?

Enforcing greenwashing exclusively through general listing rules remains structurally inadequate because the LODR Regulations and general provisions fail to address substantive misstatements. Under Regulation 98 of the LODR Regulations, stock exchanges are empowered to impose fines, freeze accounts, or suspend trading for non-compliance; however, the standard operating procedure outlined in the SEBI Master Circular for Listing Compliance6 only imposes penalties for filing delays or timeline violations rather than deceptive narrative disclosures in the BRSR.

Similarly, Section 15HB of the SEBI Act, which acts as a residual provision for contraventions where no specific penalty is provided carries a modest penalty ceiling of up to INR 1 crore. These administrative fines and the nominal LODR penalties (such as INR 2,000 per day) are entirely disproportionate to the massive financial windfalls companies secure by falsely attracting green capital and preferential financing, offering zero real deterrence.

In contrast, enforcing compliance under Section 15HA of the SEBI Act for violations of the PFUTP Regulations provides the necessary deterrent by empowering SEBI to levy severe penalties of up to INR 25 crore or three times the profit made from the violative practice, making it the vastly superior framework for securities-related greenwashing.

Conclusion

Greenwashing undermines the transparent functioning of capital markets by artificially inflating corporate sustainability credentials. Although disclosure mandates and third-party assurance systems act as vital preventive barriers, the PFUTP Regulations provide the necessary penal backstop to deter market abuse and securities fraud. As sustainable investing deepens in India, regulatory enforcement must treat ESG misstatements with the same strict accountability traditionally reserved for financial fraud, ensuring market integrity and investor trust.

- Authored by Rahul Saboo (Intern) under the guidance of Mallika Agrawal (Associate).

Footnotes

1 Circular No.: SEBI/HO/DDHS/DDHS-RACPOD1/P/CIR/2023/020 — SEBI: Dos and Don’ts relating to green debt securities to avoid occurrences of greenwashing.

2 Garg, A. (2022, June 14). Indian Legal regime for ESG, Corporate Governance – India — Mondaq.

3 N. Narayanan v. SEBI, (2013) 12 SCC 152.

4 WTM/AN/CFID/CFID/31591/2025-26 — SEBI order in the matter of Dewan Housing Finance Corporation Ltd.

5 Greenwashing as Securities Fraud: Exploring liability for misstatements in sustainability reporting (2026, July 3) — IndiaCorpLaw.

6 Circular No.: HO/49/14/14(7)2025-CFD-POD2/I/3762/2026 — SEBI Master Circular for compliance with the LODR Regulations, 2015.

Disclaimer

This publication has been prepared by RMA Legal for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, financial or any other professional advice. The information has been compiled from sources believed to be credible; however, it is provided on an “as is” basis without any representation or warranty, express or implied, as to its accuracy or completeness, and RMA Legal shall not be liable for any loss arising from reliance on this publication. Readers are advised to seek appropriate professional advice before taking any action.

We Provide Legal Solutions to Grow your Business

RMA Legal (RMA) is established by a team of dedicated professionals coming from varied streams of law. The foundations of RMA are knowledge, faith, integrity and trust.